Australian car headlines split into two camps this week, reporting the same official data. CarExpert and Carsales both said diesel "overtakes" or "retakes top spot" from EVs in October's new car sales. EV Central and GoAuto reported that EVs and hybrids combined took "more than half" of the market, with petrol and diesel sliding. Both versions are drawing on the same VFACTS release, published by the Federal Chamber of Automotive Industries (FCAI) together with Electric Vehicle Council (EVC) figures for Tesla and Polestar, which VFACTS itself doesn't capture. They're just measuring different things.
The raw numbers aren't in dispute. In October 2026, diesel vehicles sold 25,649 units (23.9% of the combined total), narrowly ahead of battery electric vehicles (BEVs) on 24,845 (23.1%), a gap of just 804 cars. Petrol sold 23,605 (22.0%), conventional hybrids 18,434 (17.1%) and plug-in hybrids (PHEVs) 11,745 (10.9%), out of a combined market of 107,493 vehicles, up 6.8% on October 2025. Toyota's diesel HiLux ute was the single best-selling model, much as it has been most months this year.
So "diesel overtook EVs" checks out, narrowly, if "EVs" means battery electric vehicles only, which is how VFACTS itself splits out fuel types. It stops checking out the moment "EVs" is read more broadly. Add hybrids and PHEVs to the BEV count and electrified vehicles of every kind totalled 55,024 sales: 51.2% of the market, and more than double diesel's tally. That's the comparison EV Central and GoAuto led with, and it's just as valid a reading of the same release.
It's also worth noting diesel's "win" wasn't a comeback. Diesel sales were down 14.7% on October 2025, while PHEV sales were up 148.6% and conventional hybrids up 3.8%. Diesel edged ahead of BEV alone mainly because BEV sales cooled slightly after a stronger August and September, not because buyers are returning to diesel utes in greater numbers. Charjin, a fact-check outlet that reviewed the same release line by line, reached a similar conclusion: the "diesel overtakes EVs" framing only holds up if you pick the narrowest possible definition of EV and ignore everything else that plugs in.
The bottom line: Partly True. Diesel genuinely outsold battery electric vehicles by a nose in October, and VFACTS' own fuel-type table supports that framing. But read "diesel overtakes EVs" as proof the electrified market is shrinking and you'd be wrong: hybrids and plug-ins kept growing fast enough that electrified vehicles of every kind still outsold diesel more than two to one.